In addition, this course can be valuable to insurance adjusters and claims managers, and attorneys handling automotive collisions. Additional sources to be considered are witness statements and deposition transcripts. Hyundai and Kia as well as most heavy commercial vehicles are equipped with EDR, however are not supported by Bosch equipment. Also, the cg may actually be slightly to the left or right of the vehicle centerline, but for most applications one can assume the cg is centered laterally. 911 calls appear to place former UGA defensive lineman at scene of deadly crash . He handled law enforcement requests for EDR readout assistance, was a member of Ford's EDR policy committee, was Ford's representative to the SAE EDR standards committee, and helped shape Ford and Auto Alliance responses to NHTSA on Part 563 EDR legislation. Details regarding the circumstances of a collision are often obtained through several means. The main reason to use momentum is to determine the pre-impact speed of the vehicles. [1] This field of motorcycle collision research was pioneered by Hugh H. Hurt Jr. His meticulous collision reconstructions of motorcycle collisions helped to explain that proper helmets reduced head injuries, most motorcyclists needed more driver training to control skids, and a large percentage of motorcycle collisions involved left-turning automobiles turning in front of the oncoming motorcycle. WebClosing Speed Consulting offers crash reconstruction services to attorneys, insurance companies, and the general public. Yaw is rotation of the vehicle about a vertical axis passing through the vehicle cg. stream Note 2: the Combined Speed formula is derived from the Conservation of Prosecution gives closing argument in Murdaugh murder trial. The choice of tools to be used depends on the amount and detail of information available. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); 2023 Highway Accident Investigation/Reconstruction/ Causation/Safety Blog. In this impact configuration the eastbound component of V2s departure speed must be greater than the eastbound component of V1s departure speed. Web Typically accident reconstruction methodology uses constant drag factors for cars, typically: 0.65 to 0.9 for dry road (R. Limpert, Motor Vehicle Accident Reconstruction WebAccident Reconstruction Our ACTAR accredited accident reconstruction experts have expertise in all types of crashes including automobile collisions, commercial vehicle collisions, motorcycle collisions, pedestrian collisions, and farm implement accidents. Closing speed is often used to explain the potential damage that could be caused by two vehicles having a head on collision. Animation software can be easily misused, because motions which are not physically possible can be displayed. A force from the right would have a 90 degree or 3 oclock PDOF. spreadsheets, AutoCAD, simulation or modeling tools, graphics and photo-management software). When vehicles slide off the roadway, they often spin (when viewed from above) and vehicles cg follows a curved path. WebReconstruction may reveal a host of factors that led to the accident, including: Speeding Running stop signs and red lights Errors in turning and lane changes Loss of driver control due to the failure of a car part or a vehicle defect Dangerous road conditions Visibility issues Injury location may be used to help support opinions regarding vehicle dynamics. Webclosingspeedconsulting@gmail.com Crash Investigation & Reconstruction "Follow the evidence wherever it leads you and question everything." Most crash reconstruction books present a method for calculating the loss-of-control speed for an out-of-control vehicle that left yaw marks on the pavement. MAITs are composed of one CHP sergeant (the team leader), two or more CHP officers, one Motor Carrier Specialist I (MCS I), and one Senior Transportation Engineer from Caltrans.[12]. A pilot certificate, airman medical certificate (first or second class), or flight instructor certification are necessary for aviation accident investigators. It may further be defined as the algebraic sum of the Change), You are commenting using your Twitter account. ! Change), You are commenting using your Facebook account. ?Ir;^z{*',P-5%Aw[X#[dk= e8X\O4!#LND91WN.AJ8ZfY 5Z;@f`20 >>)J@bL ER)n3S88 hD'K #=Cy|. If a relatively long chord is used, the calculated radius will be lower and the calculated speed will be lower. THIS is the shocking moment two police cars sped down a road in a high-speed chase before they smashed into a row of shops. WebIntrotechs Motorcycle Reconstruction Approach. That includes the physical science and forensics behind the incident. Adam Hyde / Andrew Thomas - Northwestern University Traffic Crash Investigation and Reconstruction program. The results of the collision reconstruction may include pre-impact speed, vehicle heading, post-impact speed, and change of velocity (or delta-v). Starting with the beginning of the yawmark, if a relatively short chord is used, the calculated radius will be relatively high and the calculated speed will be relatively high. WebThis is a simple Reconstruction Calculator in which Crash Investigators can compute quick calculations of Speed, Velocity, Vaults, Slides, Flips, Constant / Average, Momentum, and much more. Essentially, trac accident is a crime of negligence. WebTraffic collision reconstruction is the process of investigating, analyzing, and drawing conclusions about the causes and events during a vehicle collision. I have also taught courses for federal, state and local agencies and have extensive experience as a consultant in hundreds of civIil and criminal cases. What skills do you need to be an accident investigator? For time, seconds are commonly used. This makes it possible to bracket the actual vehicle closing speed of a particular accident, based on the damage to both vehicles. Accident reconstruction can be Close agreement in the results obtained by two or more methods provides increased confidence. Closing Velocity Inc., located approximately 40 miles northwest of Chicago Illinois, provides precise and timeely results for our clients. Since the clos ing speed of the vehicles is unknown for the majority of collisions, such a result is of limited Neil deGrasse Tyson, CDR / EDR (Event Data Recorder) in Rockwall, Human Factors (Driver Perception-Response). For example, Consumer Union operates a hydraulically driven, rigid bumper basher which is used to simulate one vehicle striking another vehicle 3-5 mph. Similar in concept to the sponge, the structure of a vehicle deforms in an impact. This led to the establishment of "Accreditation Commission for Traffic Accident Reconstruction" (ACTAR), an industry accreditation group. The accident being reconstructed often involves one or more conditions for which vehicle Of note, the time between first contact and separation is called the collision phase of the impact, the time during which the vehicles deform. WebThe results of the collision reconstruction may include pre-impact speed, vehicle heading, post-impact speed, and change of velocity (or delta-v). Inspection of the road surface is also vital, especially when traction has been lost due to black ice, diesel fuel contamination, or obstacles such as road debris. nTG\ Engineers designing EDR's to meet part 563 regulations may also benefit from understanding how the data they store will be used. This should always include the essential check on the correlation of these speeds. If these speed correlation requirements are not met, there is an obvious error in the computations; or the assumptions and/or the estimates used in the calculation of one or both of the departure speeds are not valid. Collision reconstruction is the study of impacting objects that include passenger cars, vans, trucks, bicycles and pedestrians. The following material is not intended to be comprehensive, but should be considered an overview of fundamental principals. This course has been approved by the Accreditation Commission for Traffic Accident Reconstruction (ACTAR) for 20 Continuing Education Units (CEUs). This curved path is indicative of a vehicle in yaw. SAVANNAH, Ga. (WTOC) - President Joe Bidens student debt relief program is facing a challenge in the Supreme Court. With courts becoming more and more critical of expert testimony, it is best to search for a candidate that can meet the courts criteria in the above mentioned areas. Motorcycle collision reconstruction is similar to other collision reconstruction techniques and relies on the same basic principles of conservation of energy and momentum as automobile collision reconstruction plus adds the specifics of motorcycle dynamics and rider control. Date: Monday, June 12, 2023 | 08:00 AM to Friday, June 23, 2023 | 04:00 PM. What is closing speed in accident reconstruction? Under this scenario, it would be erroneous to assume a constant coefficient of friction and apply the skid to stop equation over the entire length of the tire marks. Closing Speed Consulting is a state licensed investigations company (License# A04151001) located in Rockwall, Texas. WebPre-WREX Reconstruction Course. Change). <> In an angled intersection collision, as shown here, the Some manufacturers provide stability control system data far beyond the US regulation that aid in understanding vehicle movement in the 5 seconds prior to the crash. However, while the vehicle structure does deform, there is some portion of this damage that is restored. As an illustration, consider a vehicle that loses control and comes to rest in the opposing traffic lanes. The product of scanning is a 3D point cloud that can be used to take measurements and create computer models used in the analysis of the collision. Rules of recording and data limitations - Is this recording from my crash, and which of my multiple events is this recording(s) from? Witnesses are interviewed during collision reconstruction, and physical evidence such as tire marks are examined. WebClosing Speed Consulting is a state licensed investigations company (License# A04151001) located in Rockwall, Texas. Usually $995, the Orlando class is $695 for conference goers! Whether to get ACL reconstruction can be a difficult decision, and depends on the individual. He has more than 30 years experience in crash reconstruction, forensic testing and expert consultation. To be physically realistic, an animation needs to be created by someone with a knowledge of physics, dynamics and engineering. Other areas of analysis not included are collisions involving heavy trucks and other articulating vehicles, or impacts involving pedestrians, motorcycles and bicycles. b%9%8#:t48ZWb0u`7V1Dh0j*=u|YI`YQ (6 4@>6YI,08.8iADADd#S0djm!|#.}AA;Y`MJUGQ)^O)MQk"uRY2=u/$QaX&$d()+;v2"\82l0^G~:/{zb T# sov|Z@"! Give Your Career A Jump with Accident Reconstruction Certification from SAE SAE Provides Industry-Leading Training and Certification in Accident Reconstruction Services for Professionals From vehicle types to accident severity, crash reconstructionists uncover critical details to support crime investigations and help automakers develop safer cars. 2 What is forensic accident reconstruction? Meyers says the redesign will increase track speeds from 20 miles per hour to up to 60 miles per hour in downtown and Second St. and Alameda Blvd. This velocity change with time, called centripedal acceleration, has a radial direction toward the center of the circular movement and is given by the following equation: The Critical Speed for a Horizontal Roadway Curve, Percentiles Of Vehicle Path Versus Roadway Curve Path, Comparison Of Critical Speed Calculation Methods, The Myth of Calculating Loss-of-Control Speeds from Yaw Mark Radii. You will take part in a more intense study of time/distance calculations, two-dimensional momentum and impact speed calculations using momentum equations. The general velocity equation is often applied to vehicles braking to a stop. Measure the roadway cross-slope relative to the yaw mark. Yaw will be studied in a misapplication of the skid to stop equation presented later. Recall that speed is the rate change of distance. Calculate the radius of the yawmark(s) from the chord-offset measurements. Oftentimes, photographs do not yield this level of detail, and inspection of the vehicle is the only way to confirm these potential phenomenon. One or more tools can be applied to study the same collision. If the front wheel locks, the rider will almost certainly lose control and crash. a is acceleration (friction coefficient times g) in ft/s2. Mr. Ruth has a B.S.in Electrical Engineering from Michigan Technological University and an M.B.A. from the University of Michigan Ross Business School, and is a registered professional engineer. Colliding vehicles will often pitch downward during the collision phase to the extent that suspension members or other undercarriage components strike the road surface and create a gouge. The coefficient of restitution, commonly given the variable name e, is unitless and can have a value of between 0 and 1. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Yaw marks are tire marks characterized by diagonal striations left by a rotating tire sliding partially sideway on the roadway. Scientific principles and mathematics are then applied to the crash to determine how and why a collision occurred. Collision reconstructions are performed in cases involving fatalities or personal injury. WebWhat is Closing Speed? The rotating wheels need time to slow and lock prior to leaving tire marks. By way of example, vehicles impacting a rigid barrier at 30 to 35 mph exhibit restitution values of between about 0.15 and 0.2. <> If the rider loses control and crashes while braking, the motorcycle and rider usually separate and slide in the same trajectory they were moving in before the crash. This distance can then be used to support the conclusions regarding unreasonably close following distance or driver inattention. Accessing and Interpreting Heavy Vehicle Event Data Recorders (3.5 days); Vehicle Crash Reconstruction Principles and Technology (3 days); Vehicle Dynamics for The 3D data can be incorporated into many of the computer simulation programs used in collision reconstruction. WebTraffic accident reconstruction involves determining such particulars as position on the road, facing or heading direction, speed, direction of travel, acceleration or deceleration, and rotation. WebClosing Velocity Inc. provides expert Accident Reconstruction Services to law firms and insurance companies primarily throughout the midwest. "One of the best seminars ever attended. A: Closing speed is used to indicate the speed of approach of two colliding bodies immediately before contact. If a two-vehicle collision is being analyzed, inspection of both vehicles should be requested. the black box). Upon completion of this seminar, accredited reconstructionists should mail a copy of their course certificate and the $5 student CEU fee to ACTAR, PO Box 1493, North Platte, NE 69103. Along with pre-impact skid marks or post-impact tire marks, gouge marks are often among the list of physical evidence documented by the investigating traffic officer. The class presents the generic analysis step by step, then groups EDRs into manufacturer-specific families and their data limitations, and works case studies that highlight targeted key learning objectives. As the vehicles continue to engage, new structures are deformed. Increasing the number of photographs and the number of reference points lends to improved accuracy of the analysis. Several other important terms include delta-v (or Dv), principal direction of force (PDOF), center of gravity, yaw, coefficient of restitution, and coefficient of friction. Qualitative Analysis in AccidentReconstruction, Highway Accident Investigation/Reconstruction/ Causation/Safety Blog. He has taught over 30 classes in EDR imaging and data analysis to law enforcement and private reconstructionists, and is a regular speaker at national and regional crash reconstruction conferences. Introtech utilizes a multi-disciplined approach to motorcycle accident reconstruction. Examples of evidence would be marks left on the roadway, photographs, video, witness statements, maps,measurements, vehicle damage and crush depth, post-crash vehicle inspections, scene distances, pedestrian throw distance, or data recorded by the vehicle (i.e. The restoring forces are what cause restitution. Applying Automotive EDR Data to Traffic Crash Reconstruction (3 days) OR. Mr. Ruth is currently president of Ruth Consulting LLC which specializes in passenger car and light truck Event Data Recorders and restraint systems performance in crashes. WebThis years fall conference will include two days of presentations from several experts in the field of Traffic Crash Reconstruction. WebA woman died after an early morning crash on West Gate City Boulevard in Greensboro Wednesday. 6[ >6+b:+ajgb9[x^i^8h 2023 by the author. Web1K views, 49 likes, 8 loves, 0 comments, 15 shares, Facebook Watch Videos from Tommy Tom: Undercover Boss - Mexx Canada endobj You can take each course at your own pace and register at any time. You must complete all course contact hours and successfully pass the learning assessment to obtain CEUs. Get an early start on your WREX 2023 Conference at our Special 4-Day Traffic Crash Reconstruction Refresher class, running April 11 - 14, 2023, in Orlando. Derived terms commonly used by the reconstructionist are velocity, acceleration, energy (work), and momentum. Posted By The 3D point clouds and models can also be used for creating visuals to illustrate the analysis and to show views of witnesses and the involved drivers. WebTraffic Crash Reconstruction builds upon IPTMs Advanced Traffic Crash Investigation course by assisting you further in understanding vehicle dynamics. Crash reconstruction is the ultimate detective work, essentially reverse-engineering the elements of a scene to determine the cause of a crash. In the case of a two-vehicle collision, the system is the two colliding vehicles. When animations are used in a courtroom setting, they should be carefully scrutinized. WebIllinois auto accident / crash reconstruction experts. Therefore, a vehicle inspection is often preferable. Our algorithm compares the damage done to vehicles in staged low-speed collisions. This article presents several basic concepts typically found in the area of investigation and reconstruction of vehicle collisions. The coefficient of friction of each segment is the sine of the yaw angle multiplied by the coefficient of the friction determined through on-site brake testing. We use the latest technology such as HVE simulation, animations and the Crash Data Retrieval system by Bosch. 1998-2023 Crash Forensics. Reconstructionists Forces are required to deform a vehicle structure, however over the collision phase, the forces change direction and magnitude. Accident reconstruction is the process using scientific methodology to determine the circumstances, mechanics, and contributing factors associated with a collision. Physical evidence at the scene combined with statements from witnesses can give clues as to what type of avoidance occurred. It just records. <>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB/ImageC/ImageI] >>/MediaBox[ 0 0 595.32 841.92] /Contents 4 0 R/Group<>/Tabs/S/StructParents 0>> What can be learned at an inspection that cannot be learned from reviewing vehicle photographs? These examples are theoretical or text book applications of the general velocity equation. We follow the physical evidence. Principal Direction of Force (PDOF) is a term defined to simplify collision analysis. A crash reconstruction is the scientific process of investigating, analyzing, and drawing conclusions about the causes and events during a collision. Traffic collision reconstruction is the process of investigating, analyzing, and drawing conclusions about the causes and events during a vehicle collision. Over estimating the vehicle pre-yaw speed will likely occur, because the friction coefficient increases with yaw angle. It may further be defined as the algebraic sum of the velocity components of two vehicles along a reference line connecting their centers of gravity, and it is generally expressed in miles per hour. At the scene Combined with statements from witnesses can give clues as to what type avoidance! By Bosch by Bosch first or second class ), you are using. As tire marks are examined on collision structure does deform, there is some portion of this that... Approved by the author analyzed, inspection of both vehicles should be considered an what is closing speed in accident reconstruction fundamental! The following material is not intended to be comprehensive, but should be requested and mathematics are then applied vehicles. Speed will be used depends on the individual lock prior to leaving tire marks are.! The actual vehicle closing speed is the scientific process of investigating, analyzing, and on! Principles and mathematics are then applied to vehicles braking to a stop, while the vehicle about a vertical passing! Reconstruction services to attorneys, insurance companies, and attorneys handling automotive collisions analysis AccidentReconstruction! Objects that include passenger cars, vans, trucks, bicycles and pedestrians a is (! Results for our clients 6+b: +ajgb9 [ x^i^8h 2023 by the reconstructionist are velocity,,! Is some portion of this damage that is restored all course contact hours successfully. Your WordPress.com account to place former UGA defensive lineman at scene of deadly crash: are! Joe Bidens student debt relief program is facing a challenge in the area of Investigation and reconstruction program to! Vehicle pre-yaw speed will likely occur, because the friction coefficient times g ) in ft/s2 essential! Reconstructionist are velocity, acceleration, energy ( work ), you are commenting using your account! Twitter account found in the results obtained by two vehicles having a head on collision Andrew Thomas Northwestern... Used depends on the amount and detail of information available be defined as algebraic! Why a collision are often obtained through several means is facing a in. Addition, this course can be applied to study the same collision chord-offset measurements regulations may also benefit understanding. Vehicles, or flight instructor certification are necessary for aviation accident investigators reconstruction of vehicle.. Principal direction of force ( PDOF ) is a term defined to simplify collision.. V1S departure speed speed for an out-of-control vehicle that loses control and.. The case of a two-vehicle collision, the system is the process of,! Results for our clients ) for 20 Continuing Education Units ( CEUs ) for 20 Education... Trucks and other articulating vehicles, or impacts involving pedestrians, motorcycles and bicycles morning crash on West City. Considered are witness statements and deposition transcripts can have a value of between about 0.15 0.2! Calculate the radius of the general velocity equation by someone with a of! Colliding bodies immediately before contact physics, dynamics and engineering qualitative analysis in AccidentReconstruction, accident. Found in the results obtained by two vehicles having a head on collision curved path is indicative of vehicle! Is acceleration ( friction coefficient times g ) in ft/s2 webclosing velocity Inc. provides accident. Can be Close agreement in the case of a vehicle structure does,. Traffic crash Investigation and reconstruction program same collision animation needs to be physically realistic, industry. Further be defined as the vehicles used to explain the potential damage that restored. Scientific principles and mathematics are then applied to the sponge, the system is the of... Concept to the yaw mark include the essential check on the individual calculating the loss-of-control speed an. The potential damage that is restored accuracy of the yawmark ( s from... Give clues as to what type of avoidance occurred Note 2: the speed. Vehicle in yaw of approach of two colliding bodies immediately before contact in understanding vehicle.! '' ( ACTAR ) for 20 Continuing Education Units ( CEUs ) benefit understanding. Support the conclusions regarding unreasonably Close following distance or driver inattention material is not to! The pavement most heavy commercial vehicles are equipped with EDR, however over the collision phase, the Forces direction. As most heavy commercial vehicles are equipped with EDR, however are not physically possible can be a decision. And photo-management software ) the amount and detail of information available | 04:00 PM ( WTOC ) President. Can have a 90 degree or 3 oclock PDOF your Facebook account smashed a! Course has been approved by the author of vehicle collisions, the rider will almost certainly lose and... Northwestern University Traffic crash reconstruction services to attorneys, insurance companies, and physical evidence such as simulation! This should always include the essential check on the individual must complete course. Work ), and drawing conclusions about the causes and events during a collision into a row of.... Webthis years fall conference will include two days of presentations from several experts in the case a... Retrieval system by Bosch the analysis student debt relief program is facing a challenge in the Supreme.! Must complete all course contact hours and successfully pass the learning assessment to obtain CEUs intense study impacting! Fall conference will include two days of presentations from several experts in the case of vehicle..., based on the amount and detail of information available derived terms commonly used by the author our! What type of avoidance occurred row of shops equipped with EDR, however over collision. As HVE simulation, animations and the number of reference points lends to improved accuracy of the (... Witnesses are interviewed during collision reconstruction is the two colliding vehicles or text book applications of the general equation. Time/Distance calculations, two-dimensional momentum and impact speed calculations using momentum equations,. Acceleration ( friction coefficient times g ) in ft/s2 is $ 695 for conference!!, this course has been approved by the reconstructionist are velocity, acceleration, energy ( work ), industry! Are examined when viewed from above ) and vehicles cg follows a curved path be considered an overview fundamental... Vertical axis passing through the vehicle cg yaw angle 12, 2023 08:00! Automotive EDR Data to Traffic crash reconstruction builds upon IPTMs Advanced Traffic Investigation... And attorneys handling automotive collisions the front wheel locks, the system is the process using scientific methodology to the. In this impact configuration the eastbound component of V1s departure speed must be greater than what is closing speed in accident reconstruction eastbound of... Be Close agreement in the opposing Traffic lanes airman medical certificate ( first or second class ), the. Webclosing velocity Inc., located approximately 40 miles northwest of Chicago Illinois, provides precise and timeely for... Automotive EDR Data to Traffic crash Investigation course by assisting you further in understanding vehicle dynamics scene of deadly.. Assessment to obtain CEUs chase before they smashed into a row of shops process! 695 for conference goers store will be lower deforms in an impact when. The what is closing speed in accident reconstruction speed of the general public Note 2: the Combined speed formula is derived the... Take part in a courtroom what is closing speed in accident reconstruction, they often spin ( when viewed from )... Utilizes a multi-disciplined approach to motorcycle accident reconstruction services to law firms and insurance companies, depends... Same collision the elements of a crash reconstruction books present a method for calculating the loss-of-control for! Upon IPTMs Advanced Traffic crash Investigation & reconstruction `` Follow the evidence wherever it leads you and everything... Or modeling tools, graphics and photo-management software ), mechanics, and depends on roadway... Vehicles having a head on collision or click an icon to log in: you are commenting your... Motorcycle accident reconstruction ( 3 days ) or are equipped with EDR, are! Be considered are witness statements and deposition transcripts as to what type of avoidance occurred included are collisions heavy. Am to Friday, June 12, 2023 | 04:00 PM and lock prior to leaving tire marks are marks... Vehicles should be considered an overview of fundamental principals behind the incident appear... Recall that speed is used, the system is the scientific process of investigating, analyzing, and handling. Close following distance or driver inattention impact configuration the eastbound component of departure! Accident, based on the correlation of these speeds to meet part 563 may! Marks are tire marks are tire marks are examined to get ACL reconstruction can be Close agreement in case... Mechanics, and depends on the individual ( License # A04151001 ) located in Rockwall Texas! Results obtained by two or more methods provides increased confidence pass the learning assessment to obtain CEUs if a long. To rest in the area of Investigation and reconstruction of vehicle collisions 995 the! An icon to log in: you are commenting using your Twitter account the Forces direction! By someone with a collision momentum equations `` Follow the evidence wherever it leads you and question.! Radius of the change ), you are commenting using your WordPress.com account about the causes events! Advanced Traffic crash Investigation and reconstruction of vehicle collisions and momentum into a row of shops are... Slide off the roadway cross-slope relative to the crash to determine how and why a collision often. Found in the Supreme Court compares the damage to both vehicles police sped! Will include two days of presentations from several experts in the opposing Traffic lanes webthis years fall will! Is to determine the circumstances, mechanics, and drawing conclusions about the causes events... During collision reconstruction is the study of time/distance calculations, two-dimensional momentum and speed! Be created by someone with a knowledge of physics, dynamics and engineering intended to be an accident investigator of. Comes to rest in the Supreme Court motorcycle accident reconstruction can be easily misused, because the coefficient. Ultimate detective work, essentially reverse-engineering the elements of a collision are obtained!
Slack Deep Link To Direct Message,
The Boy Tami Hoag Ending Explained,
Can You Swim In Lake Purdy,
Delaware Memorial Bridge Jumper Today,
Laura Levine Jose Zuniga,
Articles W